Sacrilege!?!?

Started by cuthbert, August 14, 2014, 04:23:50 PM

IanR

Sorry, I don't agree.  Its an abomination and should be against the law.  There should be an international convention preventing this ever being done again.  All instances of it should be eradicated from the internet and we should transmit apologies into outer-space to ensure that alien races know that it was just a terrible mistake when they hear it 2 million years from now.

Ian   :-)






recorder
PreSonus Studio 1824
recorder
PreSonus FaderPort 8
recorder
PreSonus Studio One

AndyR

That works really well...

Just think, though - if someone had arranged, performed and recorded this anew as a cover, they'd be lauded as a tasteful genius... (I even suspect the original composers would approve and give their blessing)

But because it's using the original sound recordings, we feel a little bit twitchy and guilty about being impressed... Odd, isn't it? Especially as most of us on here know this involved a fair level of creative expertise...

It certainly got me rethinking my views on this this kinda thing...
recorder
PreSonus Studio One

(Studio 68c 6x6)
   All that I need
Is just a piece of paper
To say a few lines
Make up my mind
So she can read it later
When I'm gone

- BRM Gibb
     
AndyR is on

   The Shoebox Demos Vol 1
FAWM 2022 Demos
Remasters Vol 1

AndyR

... I imagine the living Beatles might probably have a sneaking regard for it... And I can imagine John Lennon sticking a link to it from his website! :D
recorder
PreSonus Studio One

(Studio 68c 6x6)
   All that I need
Is just a piece of paper
To say a few lines
Make up my mind
So she can read it later
When I'm gone

- BRM Gibb
     
AndyR is on

   The Shoebox Demos Vol 1
FAWM 2022 Demos
Remasters Vol 1

kenny mac

recorder
Auria Pro
recorder
Roland VS-840
recorder
Boss BR-800

Gritter

thumbs up from me. Video is very cleverly done as well.

Rata-tat-tat

recorder
Tascam DP-24