Songcrafters.org

Post Your Work => Collaborations => Topic started by: thetworegs on October 19, 2021, 07:05:00 AM

Title: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: thetworegs on October 19, 2021, 07:05:00 AM
It was raining again today so rain started play ......if anyone could help with and turn the pigs ear into a silk purse i'd be very grateful Jon on guitar me doing the squealing cheers Trevor
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: Geir on October 19, 2021, 08:30:41 AM
Sounds fab Trev !!

You need a drummer here .. I'm no good for that
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: hardlock on October 19, 2021, 01:47:58 PM
Hey Trev, I'll give the drums a try. Sounding good!
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: thetworegs on October 19, 2021, 04:14:03 PM
Quote from: hardlock on October 19, 2021, 01:47:58 PMHey Trev, I'll give the drums a try. Sounding good!
that's great Ken cant wait to hear what you do with it Thanks
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: hardlock on October 19, 2021, 08:04:50 PM
What's the chords for this? Got the drums done but trying to do the bass with limited results playing by ear. Thinking A, maybe D, G?
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: thetworegs on October 20, 2021, 11:25:42 AM
It's all around A7 G D so you were nearly there Ken ????
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: Farrell Jackson on October 20, 2021, 04:09:58 PM
Real cool version here Regs with some powerful vocals and driven guitar! I look forward to hearing it with Ken's bass and drums.
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: Mike Huntingford on December 16, 2021, 12:49:38 PM
looks like bpm is 90?

Mike
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: Mike Huntingford on December 16, 2021, 05:20:25 PM
Quote from: thetworegs on October 19, 2021, 07:05:00 AMIt was raining again today so rain started play ......if anyone could help with and turn the pigs ear into a silk purse i'd be very grateful cheers Trevor

Did this during windy afternoon.  Took your base song, added a stadium of roaring fans, drums, bass, and bit of mixing.

This is all for fun, as I am not a drummer nor a bass player as you will hear.... SO JUST FOR FUN.

Hopefully give you an idea of how your song could grow - your a fantastic singer and player.

Hope you like it
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: Zoltan on December 17, 2021, 11:41:05 AM
This was such a cool sounding track from TwoRegs that i just had to have a go. Here's a short snippet of "TwoRegs Live at Leeds 1978" with a drunken John Entwistle with hand issues, and Keith Moon when he was too close to moon.
The drums are a very live take with Alesis DM10 (Ugritone library) and the bass is the Yamaha BB414.

Only after recording this it dawned on me that this was a Led Zeppeling song :D I don't really like the original, but TwoRegs funkier take turns it into a great song!
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: thetworegs on December 18, 2021, 07:05:07 AM
Loving the live sound of both of these takes thanks gents ....I still have a take that Ken did that I haven't had a chance to put up yet as I haven't been able to get into the cellar for a while because of the building work I've been having done hopefully I'll be back in there in the beginning part of the new year
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: hardlock on December 19, 2021, 02:54:04 AM
Here's my bass and drum added mix using the 1st post on this thread. Was waiting to get the original WAV stems for less distortion in the 2nd half of the song. Wanted mine to be the "studio" version.  ::)

Also someone should add a taste of ripping lead in there somewhere as well?  8)

Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: StephenM on December 31, 2021, 07:43:03 AM
Listening to Mike H's adds to The two regs....I bloody love it...sounds like a long lost Zep track... great job.... will report on the other two as I listen...glad i dug this up...I need to get to the colab more often
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: StephenM on December 31, 2021, 07:59:44 AM
I listened to Ken's adds and I thought I wow I really dig this alot...great scott... so I took the track and ran it through the LANDR mastering software just to see what would happen... it's like a further polish...
otherwise untouched...
killer bass work and drums to go along with that great guitar and vocals... love it.
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: hardlock on December 31, 2021, 09:41:26 PM
Hey Steven, this is a good chance for me to compare what LANDR does to a file.

I first compared my posted track with yours in figure 1. Next I tried to replicate your's by tweaking mine. Tried lots of things like normalizing and such but seems like it's mostly adding compression.

Figure 2 shows mine with 3 repeated compressions using the stock setting in Audacity. To get the clipping yours has I had to bump the gain a few DBs but prefer not entering the possible distortion.

Interesting test. If you look close you'll see that different frequencies are effected by the modifications done to both. I'm sure I haven't a clue what I'm talking about when it comes to the tricks used to turn a track into a brick w/o it sounding like one!  :o

(https://songcrafters.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=31715.0;attach=192742)
(https://songcrafters.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=31715.0;attach=192743)
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: StephenM on January 01, 2022, 05:01:39 AM
Interesting stuff Ken... to be fair to Landr, and personally I like what they do, not certain about this one though, generally tracks sent to them would be mixed no higher than -4dbu and preferably -6 at most.  I have tested quite a few mixes through them and the ones that I didn't pay enough attention to "gain staging" with get sounding squashed and over compressed.  There's been a few that I have sent that were already "mastered" or were mixed to high and Landr software rejected them.
I know that I have -30db hearing loss on certain frequencies so I am sure that what I hear and others do likely aren't the same. 
for me in this case I like the result and didn't really hear any distortion added but that doesn't mean there isn't...
I do pay about a hundred a year to subscribe to get "free" masters from Landr but I probably do several hundred tracks a year as I work on some others music as well...
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: Zoltan on January 01, 2022, 06:25:34 AM
I think it really depends on what kind of track you're feeding to Landr. The less there's limiting & compression (and heavy "master" EQ) the better the results will be. The same applies to most of these "one stop shop" -solutions like Ozone. I once tried LANDR with a track that i had already done, and the end results weren't pretty. But i didn't expect anything else, i just wanted to see if there was something magical happening.
Overall i think the same principle applies here as if one was going to send the track for mastering. The track should be mixed, but it should not be mastered if one wants to use things like LANDR. So all the heavy lifting on the stereo track is best left for LANDR to handle. If one is able to make a great mix then the mastering part is just a small final touch up (with some potential fairy dust + adjusting the level etc).

The original track on this topic is already crushed to pieces. It sounds great, but the whole left channel is almost straight block. All the transients are cut of. I'm not sure if what we're hearing is the intentional guitar distortion as an effect, or if it's digital clipping. I kinda like the sound regardless. This brings it to the level of Iggy Pop remaster of the Gimme Danger album in the 90's. The master that's both loved and reviled :) I like it because there's some additional guitar stuff + grunts that's missing from the Bowie mix.

I'm not sure if Ken worked with the separate tracks (that weren't crushed?), but no amount of bringing the levels down will help with the damage that's already been done. But you can add more of it (LANDR :D).

Also i'm not sure how this comes off so i have to remind that i'm the MASTER of CRUSHING my tracks. I'm trying not to, but sometimes that's the only solution ;)
Title: Re: looking for a collab to a bit of Gallows pole
Post by: StephenM on January 01, 2022, 08:39:56 AM
I used the "mastering" software on the Boss BR1600....for a while and it does help... this is a good discussion but after reading alot about the idea of "gain staging" on posts here on SC and reading more on the net in various places I really have backed way down on the levels during track recording and mixing.  I grew up in the analog tape era where you tried to get as high a level recorded as possible without saturating the tape to overcome the noise floor... digital recording this is not a good idea as mentioned due to compression....
I try and read about this but sometimes my brain goes numb... so I try and incorporate the best practices I know.... not all my recordings are as good as others etc but they are getting better than (way better) when I first started on here...
One thing I know, I can never figure out how Tim Greene gets the kind of sounds he does off the MBR...his finishes are so good.
I am not that picky but some recordings are better than others to my ears...doesn't mean I like the song that much but I do like to hear a great recording... Keep up the good work Ken and Zoltan... and you can't go wrong every working with Trevor